Gingrich in Iowa: They Like Him but Will They Elect Him?

Gingrich gets high marks for intelligence and experience but doesn't do as well on whether he's the Republican nominee who can win the presidency for the party.

Influential local Republicans in Iowa and the early primary states see Newt Gingrich as exceptionally intelligent and experienced, which explains his emerging appeal. But the latest Power Outsiders survey also reveals that nagging doubts about Gingrich's character and electability may limit his rise.

The weekly GOP Power Outsiders poll, conducted by The Huffington Post and Patch, reaches out to local Republican activists, party officials and officeholders to observe the critical "invisible primary" that is usually a strong leading indicator of voters' preferences in presidential nomination contests. This week, we interviewed 154 Power Outsiders, including 45 in Iowa, 42 in New Hampshire, 52 in South Carolina and 15 in Florida.

Do you think Gingrich can win the Iowa caucuses? Tell us in the comments section below.

Gingrich's intellect, on regular display in a series of nationally televised candidate debates, stands out as the core of his appeal. We asked respondents for one word to describe Gingrich, and their answers were overwhelmingly positive (70 percent), with the list dominated by "intelligent," "smart," "brilliant" and "knowledgeable." In fact, synonyms describing intelligence accounted for 41 percent of all responses.

Another 16 percent answered with words that were either descriptive or not obviously positive or negative, and many of these touched on the same theme, such as "intellectual," "professor" and "historian." Just 14 percent used negative words to describe Gingrich, such as "arrogant," "old" and "baggage."

Answering a set of more specific questions about Gingrich, the local Republican activists were nearly unanimous in describing him as having "the knowledge and experience necessary to make a good president" (96 percent). Almost as many (94 percent) said he "takes stands on issues you agree with," and four out of five (80 percent) said he has "the personality and temperament necessary to make a good president."

However, the variation in intensity of opinion behind these answers begins to demonstrate the limits of Gingrich's appeal. While a remarkable three out of four (75 percent) felt strongly that Gingrich has presidential knowledge and experience (saying the phrase describes him "very well"), just 40 percent felt strongly that he has a presidential personality and temperament.

While a majority (67 percent) described Gingrich as someone who "can beat Barack Obama in the general election," nearly one-third (31 percent) did not. Compare this result to those for other candidates on previous Power Outsider surveys. As the chart below shows, these local Republicans see Gingrich as a more viable general-election candidate than Sarah Palin, Michele Bachmann and Ron Paul, but less electable than Mitt Romney, Chris Christie, Rick Perry and Herman Cain (although we asked about the latter two at the peaks of their respective popularity earlier in the campaign).

Why are so many still on the fence? We asked the 42 percent who said there is just "some chance" they might support Gingrich what he could do to win their support, and no single response dominated. But on that question and a final request for open-ended comments, slightly better than one-third of the 42 percent (or 14 percent overall) made some reference to Gingrich's personal "baggage" or what one called his "reputation as a husband."


The HuffPost-Patch Power Outsiders

Our surveys are not a scientific random sample of any larger population but rather an effort to listen to a swath of influential, local Republican activists, party leaders and elected officials in Iowa, New Hampshire, South Carolina and Florida. For more details, including a full list of participants, click here.

Tony November 16, 2011 at 09:12 PM
You really expect us to take anything a left wing rag like the Huffington Post has anything to do with seriously? You must think we were born last night. You people in the left wing media will not choose our candidate this time, so give it a rest. As Rush Limbaugh always says, you can tell who liberals fear the most by who the Democrats and the media try to destroy the most. Just look at the onslaught of attacks in the last two days. Newt is being attacked worse than Sarah Palin has. You can bet that a left wing organization is responsible for the flyers being passed around the state of Iowa detailing Newts marriages etc. The state run liberal media and the "establishment right wing media", will do their best to see to it that he is not the nominee. This tells me that Newt is the right candidate. Obama will be effectively "Newtered" after Newt is done with him in the debates.
Chris Yates November 16, 2011 at 09:26 PM
Hear, Hear! Well said Tony! www.nationalsponsor.com
B.A. Morelli November 16, 2011 at 10:07 PM
Tony and Chris. Thanks for your comments, although I must admit I am not following. What news stories are you referring to that have attacked Newt Gingrich? Much of the recent coverage of Mr. Gingrich by Patch and others has been about his strong performances in recent multi-candidate appearances and his emerging appeal. This article highlights the sentiment from our Republican insiders was "overwhelmingly positive (70 percent), with the list dominated by "intelligent," "smart," "brilliant" and "knowledgeable."


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »